![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
Hello, Space Fans!
It's past midnight in EST-land, which means nominations are now officially closed. We have 101 fandoms, and a whole lot of characters.
We've gone through and approved the nominations. We approved all of the fandoms nominated except for two:
* The Matrix (Movies)
* Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magika | Puella Magi Madoka Magica
We can't seem to find a space connection with these two fandoms. However, if the nominators (or other interested parties) want to explain how space fits in, please leave a comment! We're holding off rejecting them to give you a chance to talk to us. If we haven't heard from anyone by December 29th (the end of the dispute period), then they will be rejected.
We approved all characters in approved fandoms, except in the case of duplicate nominations. If your character was rejected, that's why.
You can see the whole tag set here.
Please take a look and tell us if we've missed anything (i.e., duplicate characters, etc.). Please note that some fandoms are uncategorized, so if it's not in the correct category, take a look in the uncategorized section.
I also have a question for the Doctor Who fans. We currently have Doctor Who in there three times: Old Who, New Who, and a general category that includes both. Would you like to leave it that way, or would you like us to keep the divide between Old and New? The current set-up means you'll be able to request and offer Old, New, or the joint category, but it also means that if you request the joint, you won't be matched with someone who only offered Old or New. If you have an opinion on keeping it this way vs. changing it, please leave a comment here.
Disputes close on December 29th, and sign-ups open on January 4th!
It's past midnight in EST-land, which means nominations are now officially closed. We have 101 fandoms, and a whole lot of characters.
We've gone through and approved the nominations. We approved all of the fandoms nominated except for two:
* The Matrix (Movies)
* Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magika | Puella Magi Madoka Magica
We can't seem to find a space connection with these two fandoms. However, if the nominators (or other interested parties) want to explain how space fits in, please leave a comment! We're holding off rejecting them to give you a chance to talk to us. If we haven't heard from anyone by December 29th (the end of the dispute period), then they will be rejected.
We approved all characters in approved fandoms, except in the case of duplicate nominations. If your character was rejected, that's why.
You can see the whole tag set here.
Please take a look and tell us if we've missed anything (i.e., duplicate characters, etc.). Please note that some fandoms are uncategorized, so if it's not in the correct category, take a look in the uncategorized section.
I also have a question for the Doctor Who fans. We currently have Doctor Who in there three times: Old Who, New Who, and a general category that includes both. Would you like to leave it that way, or would you like us to keep the divide between Old and New? The current set-up means you'll be able to request and offer Old, New, or the joint category, but it also means that if you request the joint, you won't be matched with someone who only offered Old or New. If you have an opinion on keeping it this way vs. changing it, please leave a comment here.
Disputes close on December 29th, and sign-ups open on January 4th!
Designed by ![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
chasethestars
chasethestars
Comments
It is not my nomination, but in it Kyubey is an alien who is collecting emotional energy from the girls to stop the heat death of the universe. This has been going on since cavemen.
re: Doctor Who
In the main Doctor Who one you also have Curse of Fatal Death and audio drama characters as well.
As for that... as a requester I kind of want Classic and New Who to stay together if only because it would make my request easier. But on the other hand you can only offer 2-8 characters and with classic, modern, audio drama and Curse of Fatal Death characters all mixed together I can't see many people offering any.
I do think that it should have everything together, everything all separated out or keep classic and new together and just separate the audio drama and Curse of Fatal Death characters into their own sections.
I looked it up and didn't see anything mentioning being in space or space travel. The plot doesn't sound like it has a "space" element at all.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puella_Magi_Madoka_Magica
Hopefully the nominator will show up and let us know what they were referring to?
I'm letting skies weigh in on the Doctor Who part of your comment. :)
http://i.imgur.com/lG89h0M.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/TdhJR7C.jpg
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Puella_Magi_Madoka_Magica_characters
The info about Kubey being an alien is in his section.
Those are about all of the spacey things in the series.
I was hoping to get more feedback on the Doctor Who side, but unless I do, I think I'm inclined to respect the nominators' wishes and leave it as it is. So you'll be able to request from the combined category if you like.
Thanks for replying!
Edited 2013-12-15 03:48 pm (UTC)
In that case, I guess things will have to stay the way they are, unless people say they want to completely eliminate the non-specific Doctor Who category.
Do you think that Fatal Death and the audio drama characters ought to be separated out? I haven't actually watched/listened to either--I'm going off of Wikipedia here--but on the face of it, as I said, I'm inclined to leave the combined category as is because I don't think many people will offer 'any' when thirty-four characters have been nominated, and this gives people a chance to request and offer crossovers within the canon. If you disagree, though, I'd like to hear it because I really don't know those two fandoms very well. I'm mostly a New Who girl, with a little Old Who.
For Star Trek: The Alternate Original Series you have
Janice Rand, Kevin Riley and T'Pring despite not being in the movies.
I've removed the duplicate Uhura and Sulu.
Rand, Riley, and T'Pring officially wrangled tags in AOS, and I haven't been able to find a way to remove them from one particular fandom without removing them from all. I'll try to poke at it a little more.