Previous Entry | Next Entry

Nominations Clarification #1

  • Jan. 28th, 2025 at 9:20 PM

Please read the instructions


The Excalibur Alternative - David Weber – Please nominate according to the instructions. Thank you!

Is there space in this?


A quick google did not bring up anything useful for the following fandoms. Could the nominator or a bystander please explain the space content?
Relic Master Series - Catherine Fisher
내가 키운 S급들 - 근서 | S-Classes that I Raised - Geunseo


Fandom tags


We have nominations for both Mass Effect Trilogy and Mass Effect - All Media Types. Nominators, which do you prefer? Do you want Andromeda lumped in or separated out?

We have nominations for both Warhammer 40.000 and Warhammer 40k (Novels) - Various Authors. Are these the same fandom? How do the nominators want this franchise handled?

Worldbuilding tags


Worldbuilding tags cannot be used as plot prompts. Please replace the following:
Worldbuilding: Post-Canon (DS9)
Worldbuilding: Tech lives (SW TBB)

Please be more specific about the worldbuilding or explain to me why this is the best/only way to nominate:
Farscape
Worldbuilding: Childrearing (Farscape) – Childrearing where and of which children? Peacekeepers? Among Chiana's people? Elsewhere? Would you truly be satisfied with anything?
Worldbuilding: Religion (Farscape) – Which religion? A space religion? Christianity in the canon context? Religions plural?

For All Mankind
Worldbuilding: What's happening in China (FAM) – Can you rephrase this? "State of Chinese Space Program" or whatnot? (Sorry if that's not what you're going after; I haven't started s3 yet.)

Jupiter Ascending
Worldbuilding: Childrearing (Jupiter Ascending) – Childrearing where and of which children?
Worldbuilding: Religion (Jupiter Ascending) – Which religion? A fictional space religion? A RL religion in the canon context? Religions plural?

On a Sunbeam
Worldbuilding: Restoration (On a Sunbeam) – Restoration of what? Or is this a game mechanic?

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
Worldbuilding: Religion (DS9) – Which religion? A fictional space religion? A RL religion in the canon context? Religions plural?

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds
Worldbuilding: Illyrian discrimination (STSNW)Anti-Illyrian discrimination?
Worldbuilding: Noonien-Singh descendants discrimination (STSNW) – Discrimination against Noonien-Singh descendants?
Worldbuilding: Religion (STSNW) – Which religion? A fictional space religion? A RL religion in the canon context? Religions plural?
Worldbuilding: therapy (STSNW) – Therapy where, done by whom to whom? Starfleet? Elsewhere? Is there some canonical therapy setting you want worldbuilding about?

Stargate Atlantis
Worldbuilding: Sentient Atlantis (SGA) – Is this already a thing or a plot prompt?

Other


Star Wars Crossovers
Worldbuilding: Force Hounds (Any Era) – Force Hounds only seem to appear in Dawn of the Jedi, set around 25,793 BBY. Wookieepedia doesn't have any other mentions. Star Wars Crossovers doesn't look like the best place for this, especially as this is a single era thing.
Worldbuilding: Jedi Temple Guardians (Any Era) – Nominator, I would like to remind you that you are being incredibly ambitious and opting in to both Disney Canon and Legends, from before 5000 BBY to 19 BBY for Temple Guardians. I will let this in in ~48 hours even if you don't reply, but I first wanted to warn you just in case.

Comments

irusu: "Irusu" written in kanji (Default)
[personal profile] irusu wrote:
Jan. 28th, 2025 09:12 pm (UTC)
Warhammer40K
I'm the W40K Novels nominator and I think I was confused by the plethora of W40K canon tags that popped up, and figured if it was as fractured into different things as Star Wars is then I'd pick the closest canonical tag there was to what I was nominating. I do not have a dog in the fight over what tag is used, so if the overall W40K tag is best, then I'm not going to argue against it.

Edited 2025-01-28 09:14 pm (UTC)
extrapenguin: Picture of the Horsehead Nebula, with the horse wearing a hat and the text "MOD". (ssmod)
[personal profile] extrapenguin wrote:
Jan. 29th, 2025 12:39 pm (UTC)
Re: Warhammer40K
I have no clue about what's going on with W40k, so I can't help here lol. Does the overall Warhammer 40.000 tag include many things other than the novels?
(Anonymous) wrote:
Jan. 29th, 2025 01:36 pm (UTC)
Re: Warhammer40K
The overarching Warhammer 40.000 tag also encompasses fanworks about codex/tabletop game material, video games, and animations put out by the publishers. So everything in the novels will fit into the 40.000 tag, but not everything in the 40.000 tag came from a novel.
extrapenguin: Picture of the Horsehead Nebula, with the horse wearing a hat and the text "MOD". (ssmod)
[personal profile] extrapenguin wrote:
Jan. 29th, 2025 04:32 pm (UTC)
Re: Warhammer40K
Thank you! I will merge-approve into the Warhammer 40k tag.